Searching for the 15 best eyeliners can feel overwhelming with so many formulas, finishes, and price points. The best overall pick is the stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner for its long-lasting, precise micro tip, ideal for detailed lines. The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner stands out for affordability and bold, waterproof ink. Meanwhile, the e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner offers a budget-friendly, smudge-proof option for everyday wear. Each choice involves tradeoffs, like pigmentation versus longevity or ease of application versus price. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown to help you find the perfect eyeliner for your style and needs.
Key Takeaways
- Waterproof formulas dominate the top rankings for longevity and smudge resistance.
- Gel and pencil eyeliners offer a more forgiving application for beginners, but may require sharpening or blending.
- Liquid liners provide precision but often demand a steadier hand and may be less forgiving for mistakes.
- Colorful and glitter options add fun but can be less versatile for everyday looks.
- Price varies widely; premium options tend to last longer and have finer tips, but drugstore picks can perform surprisingly well.
| eyeliner | Waterproof | Color |
|---|---|---|
| 15 Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set | Yes | — |
| L’Oreal Paris Infallible Grip | Yes | Intense Black |
| Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid P | Yes | Pitch Black |
| 15 PCS Colorful Eyeliner Pen S | Yes | — |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic I | Yes | Black |
| NYX Professional Makeup Mechan | — | Onyx, Black |
| 12 Color Gel Eyeliner Pencils | Yes | — |
| Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup P | Yes | — |
| e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Ey | Yes | Black |
| stila Stay All Day Waterproof | Yes | — |
| L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smold | — | Black |
| LemonSac 15PCS Colorful Eyelin | Yes | — |
| Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterp | Yes | Black |
More Details on Our Top Picks
15 Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, Waterproof & Smudge-proof, Multi-Function Eye Makeup Kit
This set of 15 vibrant, multi-function eyeliner pens stands out for offering a broad spectrum of colors and a variety of uses, from eyeliner to highlighters. Compared with the more traditional, single-purpose products like the NYX Epic Ink Liner, this set appeals to those who enjoy experimenting with bold or artistic makeup. The waterproof and smudge-proof formula ensures all-day wear, but the creamy texture can be tricky to control, especially for precise lines, requiring a steady hand. The multi-use design saves space and allows for quick transitions between different makeup styles, making it ideal for creative enthusiasts or performers. However, blending or layering colors might lead to smudging if not applied carefully. This pick makes the most sense for makeup lovers seeking a complete, colorful toolkit for special occasions or artistic expression.
Pros:- Vibrant, diverse color options for creative looks
- Multi-function design saves space and time
- Waterproof and smudge-proof for all-day wear
Cons:- Creamy texture may cause smudging if not applied carefully
- Colors can blend together if not used precisely
Best for: Makeup enthusiasts and creative professionals who want a versatile, colorful set for artistic looks
Not ideal for: Beginners or those seeking quick, simple eyeliner solutions, as the creamy texture and multi-color options may complicate application
- Number of Pieces:15
- Waterproof:Yes
- Smudge-proof:Yes
- Suitable For:Eye & Lip Makeup
- Features:Multi-function, Easy to Use, Long-lasting
Our verdict“This set is perfect for those who want a wide range of colors and versatile uses, especially for artistic and bold makeup styles.”
L’Oreal Paris Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Waterproof, Smudge-Resistant, 36HR Wear, Intense Black, 0.01 Oz
This gel eyeliner pencil from L’Oreal offers up to 36 hours of smudge-resistant, waterproof wear, making it ideal for all-day formal or professional looks. Compared with the liquid NYX Epic Ink Liner, this pencil provides a more forgiving and portable option, especially for those who prefer a softer, more forgiving glide. Its smooth application is suitable for sensitive eyes, though its small size means frequent reapplication might be necessary for extended wear. The limited shade options, primarily focusing on black, contrast with the vibrant variety offered by other sets like the 15 Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, but it excels in delivering a reliable, intense black finish. This makes it a strong choice for those prioritizing durability and ease of use over color variety or creative effects.
Pros:- Long-lasting up to 36 hours
- Waterproof and smudge-resistant formula
- Smooth application suitable for sensitive eyes
Cons:- Small size may require frequent reapplication
- Limited color options reduce versatility
Best for: Professionals or busy individuals seeking a dependable, long-lasting black eyeliner for daily wear
Not ideal for: Makeup artists or hobbyists looking for colorful or creative options, as the shade selection is limited
- Brand:L’Oreal Paris
- Type:Eyeliner
- Color:Intense Black
- Size:0.01 Oz
- Waterproof:Yes
- Longwear:36 hours
Our verdict“This pencil is ideal for users who need a dependable, long-wear black eyeliner for everyday or professional use.”
Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner, Satin Finish, Waterproof, Pitch Black, 0.018 Fl Oz
The Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen leverages a flexible flex-tip brush that makes precise lines effortless, perfect for creating both natural and dramatic looks. Compared to the precision of the NYX Epic Ink Liquid Liner, this pen offers a softer, more forgiving application suited for beginners or quick makeup routines. Its waterproof and smudge-proof formula ensures up to 24 hours of wear, but its small volume means frequent reapplication if used daily. The satin finish enhances softer, more natural looks, though it might not give the intense matte black finish some users desire. This pick is well-suited for those prioritizing ease and comfort over intense color density or long-term durability.
Pros:- Flexible flex-tip for easy, precise application
- Waterproof and smudge-proof for all-day wear
- Satin finish creates softer, natural looks
Cons:- May require multiple coats for deep black color
- Small volume may wear out quickly
Best for: Beginners or busy users who want quick, clean lines with minimal effort
Not ideal for: Makeup artists or enthusiasts seeking highly pigmented, long-lasting bold looks, as it may require multiple coats
- Finish:Satin
- Waterproof:Yes
- Color:Pitch Black
- Volume:0.018 Fl Oz
Our verdict“This liquid eyeliner is ideal for beginners or those seeking a quick, precise, and comfortable application for everyday use.”
15 PCS Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set Waterproof Metallic & Pearl Glitter Eyeliner Kit
This 15-piece set offers a wide array of vibrant metallic and glitter shades, making it perfect for parties, Halloween, or cosplay. Unlike the more subdued or standard options like the NYX Epic Ink, this set emphasizes eye-catching effects with high-shine finishes and multi-purpose use, including lips and highlighters. The waterproof formula ensures long-lasting, smudge-free wear, but some shades may require multiple layers for full intensity, especially on oily skin. While it provides quick application with high-precision tips, it lacks detailed shade information and may not be suitable for everyday subtle looks. This set excels for users wanting to experiment with bold, glittery, and festive styles with minimal hassle.
Pros:- Wide variety of vibrant metallic and glitter shades
- Multi-functional as eyeliner, eyeshadow, and lip liner
- Waterproof and smudge-proof for all-day wear
Cons:- Some shades need multiple layers for full color payoff
- Potentially less effective on oily skin or for long hours without touch-up
Best for: Party-goers, cosplayers, and makeup lovers looking for versatile, dazzling shades for special occasions
Not ideal for: Those seeking subtle or professional everyday makeup, as the shades are highly vibrant and glittery, which might be overwhelming for daily wear
- Number of Pieces:15
- Colors:Vibrant metallic and glitter shades
- Waterproof:Yes
- Multi-purpose:Yes
- Suitable For:Party, Halloween, cosplay, daily wear
Our verdict“This colorful, glittery set is perfect for those who want bold, festive looks with a quick, multi-use application.”
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner – Black, Vegan Formula
The NYX Epic Ink Liner provides a highly precise, matte black line with a flexible tip, ideal for creating crisp cat eyes or subtle definitions. Compared to the Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen, this liquid liner offers more control and a sharper finish, making it suitable for experienced users or those who want detailed, bold lines. Its waterproof and long-lasting formula ensures the look stays intact all day. The vegan, cruelty-free formula appeals to eco-conscious consumers, though it may require multiple coats for a fully opaque black. Its micro tip allows for fine detailing, but beginners might find it challenging to master without practice. This liner makes sense for those seeking a professional-quality finish with reliable longevity.
Pros:- Precise, micro-tip for detailed lines
- Long-lasting, waterproof, matte finish
- Vegan and cruelty-free formula
Cons:- May require multiple coats for deep black opacity
- Liquid consistency can be difficult for beginners to control
Best for: Experienced makeup users or professionals wanting precise, long-lasting lines with a matte finish
Not ideal for: Beginners or users looking for quick, forgiving application, as the liquid consistency demands steady hand control
- Type:Liquid Eyeliner
- Finish:Matte
- Color:Black
- Vegan:Yes
- Waterproof:Yes
Our verdict“This eyeliner is perfect for experienced users aiming for precise, professional-looking lines that last all day.”
NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eye Pencil, Vivid Rich Mechanical, Creamy Retractable Eyeliner – Always Onyx, Black
This retractable eyeliner stands out for its effortless application and intense pigment payoff, making it a versatile choice for quick daily looks or bold statements. Compared with the stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner, it offers a softer, creamier application that’s easier for beginners, though it might require touch-ups on oily lids. Its twist-up design eliminates the need for sharpening, saving time and mess, while its smudge-proof, long-lasting formula ensures it stays vibrant through the day. The limited shade range, mainly focusing on blacks and neutrals, could be a drawback for those seeking more variety. Still, its cruelty-free certification adds to its appeal for ethical consumers. Overall, this pick makes the most sense for those prioritizing simplicity, vivid color, and durability in a budget-friendly package.Pros:- Easy to use with twist-up design, no sharpening needed
- Long-lasting and smudge-proof formula
- Rich pigment for vivid color payoff
- Cruelty-free and PETA certified
Cons:- Limited shade options in this specific product
- May require touch-ups on very oily eyelids
Best for: Beginners or busy users who want a reliable, easy-to-apply black eyeliner with bold color.
Not ideal for: Makeup artists or advanced users needing multiple shades and precise control for intricate looks.
- Type:Mechanical Eyeliner
- Color:Onyx, Black
- Features:Retractable, Smudge-proof, Long-lasting
Our verdict“A solid, user-friendly choice for those seeking a vivid black eyeliner that’s quick to apply and lasts hours.”
12 Color Gel Eyeliner Pencils Waterproof Long Wear with Sharpener
This set of 12 gel eyeliners is ideal for users who want a broad spectrum of colors, from subtle neutrals to bold hues. Unlike the Wet n Wild Mega Last, which offers a single shade with impressive longevity, this collection provides creative flexibility but requires multiple layers for full intensity, especially in lighter shades. The gel formula delivers waterproof, smudge-proof wear, suitable for all-day or special occasion looks. The inclusion of a sharpener adds convenience, but the softer gel pencils can break if handled roughly, which is a consideration for travel or on-the-go use. This set is best suited for makeup enthusiasts and beginners eager to experiment with color and texture, though it isn’t the best choice for those seeking quick, simple liners.Pros:- Vibrant, diverse color selection
- Waterproof and long-lasting formula
- Includes a handy sharpener
- Suitable for various makeup styles
Cons:- Colors may need multiple coats for full intensity
- Gel pencils can be softer and prone to breaking
Best for: Makeup lovers and beginners eager to explore vibrant hues and creative eye looks.
Not ideal for: Users seeking quick, foolproof application with a single, dependable shade—gel pencils demand careful handling.
- Number of Colors:12
- Waterproof:Yes
- Includes Sharpener:Yes
- Suitable for:Beginners, Daily Makeup, Travel
Our verdict“A colorful, versatile set perfect for those who want to experiment with a range of eye looks and shades.”
Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof Retractable Gel Eyeliner – Charcoal
This gel eyeliner excels at delivering up to 16 hours of smudge-proof, bold color with a satin sheen, making it a reliable choice for long days or nights out. Compared with the NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil, which offers ease of use but less longevity, this product prioritizes durability and intense pigmentation. Its retractable design simplifies application, but it might require sharpening or reapplication for the most dramatic looks. The satin finish adds sophistication that works well with both daytime and evening styles. While limited in color options—primarily charcoal—its cruelty-free and vegan credentials appeal to ethically conscious buyers. This pick makes the most sense for those who want a high-performance, all-day waterproof eyeliner with a sleek, polished look.Pros:- Long-lasting up to 16 hours
- Waterproof and smudge-proof
- Cruelty-free and vegan
- Smooth, easy glide for bold lines
Cons:- Limited color options in this line
- May require sharpening or reapplication for intense looks
Best for: Users seeking a long-lasting, smudge-proof gel liner for bold, defined eyes on busy days.
Not ideal for: Casual users or beginners who prefer softer, easier-to-apply pencils in multiple colors.
- Type:Gel Eyeliner
- Finish:Satin
- Waterproof:Yes
- Longevity:Up to 16 hours
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“An excellent choice for those needing a durable, bold gel liner that stands up through sweat and tears.”
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Black
This eyeliner makes a compelling case for those who want a highly pigmented, waterproof pencil that can create dramatic looks and double as an eyeshadow base. Compared with the NYX Mechanical, it offers a creamier, more intense application, but requires sharpening after each use, which can slow down busy routines. Its waterproof formula ensures staying power, though removal may need a dedicated makeup remover—this can be a plus or minus depending on your preference. The rich black hue delivers a bold finish, suitable for lining the waterline or lash line. This product is best suited for makeup lovers and those who want a versatile, highly pigmented liner that stays put all day, despite the minor inconvenience of sharpening.Pros:- Waterproof and long-lasting
- Creamy, highly pigmented formula
- Vegan and cruelty-free
Cons:- Requires sharpening after each use
- Harder to remove without makeup remover
Best for: Makeup enthusiasts needing a waterproof, intense black pencil for bold eyes and versatile use.
Not ideal for: Travelers or those who prefer low-maintenance, retractable pencils in multiple shades for quick daily routines.
- Type:Retractable Eyeliner
- Color:Black
- Waterproof:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
Our verdict“A top pick for those who want a waterproof, ultra-pigmented black liner with versatile application options.”
stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Micro Tip
This ultra-fine liquid liner with a micro tip excels at creating precise, sharp lines, making it ideal for detailed winged looks or intricate designs. Unlike the NYX Mechanical or gel pencils, which offer ease of application, this liquid liner demands a steady hand but rewards with unmatched accuracy. Its waterproof, smudge-proof formula ensures it stays intact for hours, although the fine tip can be tricky for those new to liquid liners. The satin finish adds a subtle sophistication, perfect for polished, professional looks. While its application requires care, it’s the go-to choice for makeup aficionados who want maximum control and crisp lines in a long-lasting formula.Pros:- Provides extremely precise, fine lines
- Waterproof and smudge-proof
- Long-lasting satin finish
- Smooth application without skipping
Cons:- Requires careful, steady application
- More difficult to remove compared to pencil or gel liners
Best for: Experienced users or makeup artists aiming for precise, detailed eyeliner looks that last all day.
Not ideal for: Beginners or those seeking quick, forgiving application with a thicker line style.
- Type:Liquid Eyeliner
- Finish:Satin
- Waterproof:Yes
- Tip:Micro Tip
Our verdict“An excellent choice for experienced users needing precise, long-lasting lines for detailed eye looks.”
L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner, Black, 0.056 Oz
This eyeliner stands out for its rich, intense black color that delivers striking eye definition. It glides on effortlessly, making it suitable for both bold, smoky looks and subtle daytime wear. Compared with the Revlon ColorStay Pencil, it offers easier application without the need for sharpening, but it may smudge if not set properly, which is a drawback for long wear. Its simple formula and single shade keep it straightforward but limit versatility in color options. This pick makes the most sense for users seeking a reliable, high-impact pencil that works well for quick application or detailed eye makeup.
Pros:- Richly intense black color for dramatic eyes
- Glides on effortlessly for easy application
- Suitable for both bold and everyday looks
Cons:- May smudge if not set properly
- Limited to a single color option
Best for: Makeup enthusiasts who want a versatile, easy-to-apply eyeliner for daily and dramatic looks
Not ideal for: People who need a completely smudge-proof, all-day wear without touch-ups, as it may smudge without setting
- Color:Black
- Size:0.056 Oz
- Count:1
Our verdict“This eyeliner is ideal for those who want an easy-to-use pencil that delivers bold definition with minimal fuss.”
LemonSac 15PCS Colorful Eyeliner Pen Set, Eye Shadow Pencil, Pearl & Matte Metallic Glitter Eyeliner for Women
This set shines for its wide array of 15 vibrant colors, making it perfect for experimenting with different eye looks—from subtle daytime styles to bold, glittery party makeup. The waterproof and smudge-proof formulas ensure long-lasting wear, comparable to the Revlon ColorStay Pencil, but the creamy texture can be challenging for precise lines, especially for beginners. Some shades require multiple layers to achieve full intensity, which may be inconvenient for quick routines. This set is best suited for makeup lovers who enjoy color experimentation or need a variety for special occasions, rather than for those seeking a simple, everyday eyeliner.
Pros:- Variety of 15 vibrant colors for diverse looks
- Waterproof and smudge-proof for all-day wear
- Multi-functional as eyeliner, eyeshadow, and highlighter
- Great for gifting or special occasions
Cons:- Creamy texture may be difficult to control for precise lines
- Some colors need multiple applications for full intensity
Best for: Creative makeup enthusiasts and those who love colorful, multi-purpose eye products
Not ideal for: Individuals seeking a precise, easy-to-control eyeliner for everyday use, as the creamy texture can be hard to manage
- Number of Pieces:15
- Color Types:Pearl and Matte
- Waterproof:Yes
- Smudge-proof:Yes
- Uses:Eyeliner, Eyeshadow, Highlighter
Our verdict“This colorful set is perfect for adventurous users who want variety and long-lasting performance, but less so for those prioritizing precision and quick application.”
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 201 Black, 2 pack
This duo offers a reliable option for all-day, waterproof wear, with the added convenience of a built-in sharpener and smudger. It compares favorably to the LemonSac set in terms of longevity, capable of lasting up to 24 hours without smudging or fading. However, frequent sharpening can be a drawback, especially for those who prefer a fine tip or quick touch-ups. The all-black shade and matte finish make it versatile for subtle or dramatic looks, but the limited color palette means less variety. This pack is well-suited for users needing dependable, long-lasting black eyeliner for waterline or tightline use, especially in humid or active environments.
Pros:- Long-lasting and waterproof for up to 24 hours
- Includes built-in sharpener and smudger for versatility
- Creates both subtle and dramatic looks with intense matte color
Cons:- Requires frequent sharpening for a fine tip
- Limited to black shade in this pack
Best for: Individuals who need a durable, waterproof pencil for all-day wear and waterline application
Not ideal for: Users looking for a range of colors or a quick, maintenance-free application, since it requires sharpening and only offers black
- Color:Black
- Finish:Matte
- Waterproof:Yes
- Includes:Built-in sharpener, smudger
- Duration:Up to 24 hours
- Pack Size:2 pack
Our verdict“This waterproof pencil is ideal for those who prioritize durability and water resistance over color variety or quick touch-ups.”
How We Picked
Products were evaluated based on performance, ease of use, build quality, longevity, and versatility. We prioritized formulas with proven waterproof and smudge-proof capabilities, as these are most important for long-lasting wear. Ease of application was assessed through tip design and user-friendly features, especially for beginners. Value was considered by comparing price points against performance durability. Rankings reflect a balanced view of these factors, with the top picks offering the best combination of quality and usability for different types of users.Factors to Consider When Choosing 15 Best Eyeliners
Choosing the right eyeliner involves considering several key factors that influence your overall experience and results. Understanding these will help you avoid common pitfalls, such as selecting a product that smudges easily or is difficult to apply. The right product depends on your skill level, specific needs, and preferred look, so weigh these considerations carefully before purchasing.Formula and Finish
Eyeliners come in various formulas, including liquid, gel, pencil, and felt-tip pens. Each offers a different finish—matte, glossy, metallic, or shimmer—and suits different styles. Liquid liners provide sharp, precise lines perfect for winged looks, while gels and pencils tend to be more forgiving and easier to blend for softer effects. Consider your comfort with applying different textures and the look you want to achieve when choosing a formula.
Waterproof vs. Non-Waterproof
Waterproof eyeliners excel in long-lasting wear, especially in humid or rainy conditions, and resist smudging throughout the day. However, they can be more difficult to remove and may cause irritation for sensitive eyes. Non-waterproof options are easier to remove and often feel softer on the skin, making them suitable for everyday or casual looks. Think about your environment and how much time you’re willing to spend on removal when selecting between these types.
Application Ease
For beginners, a pencil or felt-tip pen with a soft tip can make application more manageable, reducing the risk of mistakes. More experienced users may prefer precise liquid liners with fine tips for detailed work. Also, features like built-in sharpeners or flexible brush tips can influence ease of use. Choosing a product that matches your skill level helps ensure a satisfying experience and better results.
Longevity and Smudge Resistance
Consider how long the eyeliner stays intact without fading or smudging, especially if you have oily eyelids or need all-day wear. Waterproof, smudge-proof formulas tend to last longer, but may require specialized removers. Conversely, some formulas might need touch-ups throughout the day, which can be inconvenient. Prioritize longevity if your schedule demands all-day wear or if you live in a humid climate.
Price and Value
High-end eyeliners often deliver finer tips, more pigment, and longer durability, but budget options can deliver impressive results at a fraction of the cost. Look for products that strike a balance between affordability and performance, especially if you wear eyeliner daily. Bulk sets or multi-packs may offer added value for those who use multiple shades regularly.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose between liquid and pencil eyeliner?
Liquid eyeliners are ideal for creating sharp, precise lines and dramatic wings, making them a favorite for bold looks. Pencil eyeliners, on the other hand, are more forgiving and easier to blend, making them suitable for softer, everyday styles. Your skill level also matters; beginners often find pencils less intimidating, while experienced users may prefer the control liquid liners offer. Consider your typical makeup look and comfort level before deciding.
Are waterproof eyeliners worth the extra cost?
Waterproof eyeliners are a solid investment if longevity and smudge resistance are priorities. They tend to last through humidity, tears, and sweat, reducing the need for touch-ups. However, they can be more challenging to remove and sometimes cause irritation, especially for sensitive eyes. If you rarely wear eyeliner or prefer easy removal, a non-waterproof option might suit you better, saving both time and potential discomfort.
Can I wear colorful or glitter eyeliners daily?
Colorful and glitter eyeliners are fun ways to experiment with your look, but they may be less versatile for everyday wear. If you love bold, creative styles, choose high-quality formulas that don’t flake or smudge easily. For daily use, sticking to classic black, brown, or dark hues can be more practical, while saving colorful options for special occasions. Always consider your wardrobe and personal style when incorporating these shades.
How often should I replace my eyeliner pencil or gel pot?
Most eyeliners should be replaced every 3 to 6 months to prevent bacterial buildup and maintain quality. Pencils that are sharpened regularly tend to stay fresher longer, but once they become dry or crumbly, it’s time for a new one. Gel and cream formulas may last a bit longer if kept properly sealed, but watch for changes in texture or smell, which can indicate spoilage. Regular replacement ensures safety and optimal performance.
What’s the best way to remove waterproof eyeliner?
Removing waterproof eyeliner typically requires a dedicated eye makeup remover, preferably oil-based or formulated specifically for waterproof products. Gently massage the remover onto closed eyelids using a cotton pad, allowing it to dissolve the makeup. Avoid rubbing harshly, which can irritate delicate skin. Follow up with a gentle cleanser to remove any residue and moisturize the area afterward for comfort and skin health.
